Skip to content

BlogGovernance

The non-solicitation clause in IT consulting: what it protects

A non-solicitation clause stops the client hiring the consultant. It binds two firms, not the employee, and since 2021 must be proportionate under French law.

10 min read

A non-solicitation clause in an IT consultancy contract forbids the client from hiring, directly or otherwise, the consultant the consultancy has placed with it, during the engagement and for an agreed period after it ends. In France, where these firms are called ESN (entreprises de services du numérique), the clause protects the firm’s investment in that consultant and nothing else: it binds two companies, it does not bind the employee, and since a 2021 ruling it is valid only if it stays proportionate to the interest it defends.

What follows is general information on the state of French law, not legal advice: a specific clause, in a specific contract, should be reviewed with a lawyer.

What does a non-solicitation clause actually protect?

It protects the cost of having found, recruited, trained and placed a consultant, and the margin the engagement was supposed to earn. When a client hires directly the consultant it has watched work for two years, the consultancy loses the engagement, the consultant and the revenue of the following years in one go, without having done anything wrong.

The scenario follows the ordinary calendar of departures. We described in the piece on the consultant nobody has called how 30% of new joiners leave within their first six months, and how departures then peak between the sixth and twelfth month and again around the third year. The third year is also when the consultant knows the client’s systems best, and when the client has the most reason to bring them in-house.

The clause protects neither the consultant, nor the relationship, nor the day-to-day margin. An engagement whose price has not moved in three years loses its margin at renewal long before the question of a direct hire arises, and no clause makes up for that. It serves one purpose only: to make it expensive for the client to take the consultant for itself.

How does it differ from a non-compete clause?

The non-compete clause sits in the employment contract and binds the employee; the non-solicitation clause sits in the commercial contract and binds the client. The consultant is a third party to the second, which changes both its conditions of validity and what can be expected of it.

For the non-compete clause, the social chamber of the Cour de cassation, France’s highest court for civil and labour matters, set cumulative conditions in a ruling of 10 July 2002 (n° 00-45.135) that have not moved since: the clause must be essential to protect the company’s legitimate interests, limited in time and space, take account of the specific features of the employee’s job, and include financial compensation paid by the employer. Without compensation it is void, and that last condition is what makes it expensive.

The non-solicitation clause escapes this regime. The commercial chamber held on 10 May 2006 (n° 04-10.149) that its validity does not depend on financial compensation for the employee, then on 11 July 2006 (n° 04-20.438) that it is “neither a variant nor a refinement” of the non-compete clause. In the first case the Court added that only the employee can rely on the harm caused by a clause without compensation, which closes that argument to a company hoping to use it to escape its penalty.

There is a third clause, and it is the one that most often catches people out. An employment contract that forbids a consultant from working for the consultancy’s clients after leaving is not a non-solicitation clause, whatever its heading: the social chamber treats it as a non-compete clause, for instance in a ruling of 30 May 2007 (n° 06-40.655) on a “client protection” clause. Without financial compensation, it falls.

What makes it valid since the 2021 ruling?

Since the commercial chamber’s ruling of 27 May 2021 (n° 18-23.261 and 18-23.699), a non-solicitation clause is lawful only if the restriction it places on freedom to work and freedom to do business is proportionate to the legitimate interests to be protected, given the purpose of the contract. It was the first time the Court had set out this test for such a clause challenged by one of the contracting companies itself.

The facts show that a time limit is not enough. Five office-supply distributors had signed a charter forbidding them to hire the sales staff of the other signatories, including those who had left less than a year earlier. The Dijon court of appeal had upheld the clause because it was limited in time and fell outside the non-compete regime; the Cour de cassation quashed that ruling for failing to check proportionality.

The relationship between a consultancy and its client is less exposed than that case, which involved competitors on the same market. Commentators nonetheless point to a risk specific to our sector: a very broad clause could be read as the employer’s way of avoiding the cost of a non-compete clause with compensation.

What legal commentary recommends writing down follows fairly directly: what counts as solicitation, who is covered, whether the commitment is reciprocal, the duration, the penalty, and the interest the consultancy means to protect. No statute sets a maximum duration, which is precisely why the duration must be justified by the investment protected rather than by habit. In a standard-form contract, a clause that is too one-sided can also be deemed unwritten under article 1171 of the Civil Code.

Finally, the employee is not without recourse. As a third party they cannot ask for the clause to be annulled, but the social chamber accepted on 2 March 2011 (n° 09-40.547) that they could be compensated for the harm done to their freedom to work. An excessive clause can therefore cost twice: the penalty you do not get, and the damages you owe.

What does a breach cost, and can a court reduce the penalty?

Many clauses provide for a fixed sum payable by the client if it hires the consultant, and that sum is a penalty clause (clause pénale) within the meaning of article 1231-5 of the Civil Code. The judge can reduce it, even on their own motion, if it is manifestly excessive, and any term claiming to prevent this is deemed unwritten.

In practice, two ways of setting the sum come up most: a number of months of the consultant’s salary, or a number of months of what the engagement billed. We found no reliable public statistics on the amounts actually used, and we would rather not invent one. What can be said with certainty is that the amount holds up better the closer it is to the real loss: the cost of replacing the consultant, the margin lost over the remaining term, and the time spent on the bench if nobody is ready to take the seat.

That last item can be costed. A consultant between engagements costs on average €5,480 a month in France, as we detailed in the real cost of bench time, and that is a firmer basis than a round multiple chosen because it sounds frightening: a sum you can explain line by line stands up better to article 1231-5.

Two procedural details matter more than people think. Unless the breach is final, the penalty is only due after formal notice, which means writing to the client rather than simply invoicing. And a clause that forbids “soliciting” requires proof that the client made an approach, whereas a clause that forbids “hiring” only needs the fact: the difference shows the day the consultant says they applied on their own initiative.

Can a non-solicitation clause become a cartel?

Yes, when it stops being ancillary to a contract and becomes a general agreement between competitors. On 11 June 2025, the Autorité de la concurrence, France’s competition authority, imposed €29.5 million in fines for no-poach agreements in engineering, technology consulting and IT services (decision 25-D-03), including €24 million for Alten, €3.6 million for Bertrandt and €1.9 million for Expleo France; Ausy, now Randstad Digital, received immunity as the leniency applicant.

What was sanctioned were gentlemen’s agreements by which competing consultancies gave up recruiting each other’s staff. The authority classed them as a sharing of sources of supply, prohibited by article L. 420-1 of the Commercial Code, because staff are the essential parameter of competition in this sector.

The non-solicitation clauses written into partnership contracts, on the other hand, were found to have no anticompetitive object in that case, given their limited scope and their objectives, and no effect was shown. The authority took care to say that this analysis does not prejudge future cases, and the decision is under appeal before the Paris court of appeal. The line that emerges is clear for a consultancy: a clause attached to an engagement, limited and justified, is not a pact between competitors, and it must never become a cover for one.

What can the clause not prevent?

It cannot stop the consultant from leaving. They resign, join another consultancy, go freelance or join an employer that never signed anything with you, and the clause cannot be enforced against them because they are not a party to it. What it prevents is one particular client recruiting them without paying, and only for the agreed period.

Nor does it settle the case of a consultant who returns to the same client through another consultancy. Depending on the wording, a clause covering hiring “directly or indirectly” may catch that workaround, and a clause that only covers direct hiring will not; the signed text decides, not the intention. Preferred-supplier agreements with large accounts complicate matters further, since the template contract is often the client’s own and the file is negotiated before the first order.

Above all, it does not prevent what comes before the departure. A consultant thinking of moving to the client rarely tells the consultancy, and the signal shows up in conversations that never took place rather than in a contract. The clause is a safety net, and a net only catches those who fall.

What should you do with the clauses you already have?

Start by knowing which ones exist, and until when. A clause that runs “twelve months after the end of the engagement” is only worth something if someone knows the end date of each engagement, whereas that date often sleeps in a framework contract nobody reopens.

Next, reread the wording with three questions: what is forbidden (soliciting, or hiring), who is covered (the consultant placed, or all staff), and how the sum is justified. A clause covering every member of the consultancy’s staff for several years, at a client that only sees two consultants, is exactly the kind the 2021 ruling invites people to challenge.

Finally, treat the clause as a negotiating tool rather than a weapon. When a client wants to bring a consultant in-house, the agreed sum can become the basis of an amicable settlement, close to a recruitment fee, and the commercial relationship survives it. The letter that opens that discussion leaves the company and commits its signature: it is reviewed and sent by a person, under the rule we apply to everything an AI drafts for the outside world.

This is the kind of calendar we have Balt keep: the end date of each engagement, the duration of each clause, the alert when a consultant concerned leaves the company. Reading the contract and talking to the client remain the managing director’s job, and their lawyer’s.

One question comes before all the others: the best protection against a direct hire is a consultant who has no wish to leave, and that conversation is lost for want of a written date, long before any clause comes into play.

Frequently asked questions

  • Does a non-solicitation clause stop the consultant from resigning?

    No. It commits the client to the consultancy, and the consultant is not a party to the contract that contains it. The consultant can resign and join another consultancy or another employer; only the client is exposed to the penalty if it hires the consultant during the period covered.

  • Does the consultant have to be paid compensation?

    Not for a non-solicitation clause agreed between the consultancy and its client: the Cour de cassation has held since 2006 that its validity does not depend on it. A clause in the employment contract that forbids the consultant from working for the consultancy’s clients, however, is treated as a non-compete clause, and without financial compensation it is void.

  • How long can a non-solicitation clause last?

    No statute sets a maximum. The court checks that the restriction on freedom to work and freedom to do business remains proportionate to the interest protected, which argues for covering the engagement and a limited period after it ends, justified by the investment the consultancy wants to protect.

  • Can a court reduce the penalty set in the clause?

    Yes. A fixed sum due on breach is a penalty clause, and article 1231-5 of the French Civil Code lets the judge reduce it, even on their own motion, if it is manifestly excessive. Any term that tries to prevent this is deemed unwritten.

Sources

  1. LPA-CGR Avocats, A. Bensoussan and J. Mendes, Quel avenir pour les clauses de non-sollicitation ? (Option Droit & Affaires, September 2021)lpalaw.com
  2. CMS Francis Lefebvre, Clause de non-sollicitation portant atteinte à la liberté d’entreprendre (Cass. com., 27 May 2021)cms.law
  3. Autorité de la concurrence, Decision 25-D-03 of 11 June 2025 (engineering, technology consulting and IT services)autoritedelaconcurrence.fr
  4. La Lettre des Réseaux, Le nouvel article 1231-5 du Code civil relatif à la clause pénalelettredesreseaux.com
  5. Soulier Bunch, Clause de non-concurrence et clause de non-sollicitation de clientèlesoulierbunch.com

Balt does this work

Read next

Give Balt its first job.

Thirty seconds to add it to Teams and get to work.

Try for free